Wolverine v. Batman v. Capt. America

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

spideydude said:

admin said:

Wolverine is skilled but I wouldn't say he's a more skilled fighter than Cap or Batman, give them his powers and they kick his ass.

if they have his powers and he doesnt then yes hes screwed. but if they fight no powers no bat toys just hand to hand. wolvie takes them both one at a time. and wolverine has more courage that batman and cap. even if wolvie knows hes gonna get his ass kicked he will still go for it. he doesnt stand down.

I'm saying if they all were exactly the same physically then Wolverine would lose, he wins because of his physicality.

[spideydude]

batman is a human being. wolverine is considered an animal in a way. he has a sense of emotion before action is taken. kinda like DD for example

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

spideydude said:

batman is a human being. wolverine is considered an animal in a way. he has a sense of emotion before action is taken. kinda like DD for example

DD has crazy senses, but Batman has also trained himself to crazy levels!

[alfheim]

Yeah but Batmans still gonna get finished first off. Shame.

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

alfheim said:

Yeah but Batmans still gonna get finished first off. Shame.

True, he's at a disadvantage...

[kuwabara]

Wolverine wins. There really no doubts about it

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

I'd give him the majority in this situation, I have to agree.

[jasonk3]

I saw the exact same thread at KMC...and the same people...*Panics* ...what the hell is going on? jks...id say wolverine for the win.

[warmunger]

Captain America. Team America....F**K YEAH!!!

[Magic attack]

Cap and Batman's best chance is to try and take Wolverine down 2 on 1. (without getting into who has taken "100+ ton shots" from whom, because all 3 have shown capable of doing so)

I still give it to Wolverine though for a majority. It is debatable as to who is the most skilled of the three, but Wolverine has the claws, adamantium and healing factor.

admin said:

spideydude said:

if they have his powers and he doesnt then yes hes screwed. but if they fight no powers no bat toys just hand to hand. wolvie takes them both one at a time. and wolverine has more courage that batman and cap. even if wolvie knows hes gonna get his ass kicked he will still go for it. he doesnt stand down.

I'm saying if they all were exactly the same physically then Wolverine would lose, he wins because of his physicality.

I figure Wolverine's major advantages are his healing factor, Adamantium laced bones, and his claws. If you take away 2 of the 3 of those, he loses a majority versus either Batman or Captain America.


But as the thread stands Wolverine wins.

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

shakezula said:

Cap and Batman's best chance is to try and take Wolverine down 2 on 1. (without getting into who has taken "100+ ton shots" from whom, because all 3 have shown capable of doing so)

I still give it to Wolverine though for a majority. It is debatable as to who is the most skilled of the three, but Wolverine has the claws, adamantium and healing factor.

admin said:

I'm saying if they all were exactly the same physically then Wolverine would lose, he wins because of his physicality.

I figure Wolverine's major advantages are his healing factor, Adamantium laced bones, and his claws. If you take away 2 of the 3 of those, he loses a majority versus either Batman or Captain America.


But as the thread stands Wolverine wins.

Agreed.

[The Slayer]

Wolverine haunts us here even after we have left KMC. THE HORROR! #scary#

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

slayer said:

Wolverine haunts us here even after we have left KMC. THE HORROR! #scary#

He haunts just about everything lol.

[The Slayer]

Why are people so damn crazy about the hairy, metal-boned, midget?

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

slayer said:

Why are people so damn crazy about the hairy, metal-boned, midget?

He's actually an enjoyable character when written properly.

[The Slayer]

admin said:

slayer said:

Why are people so damn crazy about the hairy, metal-boned, midget?

He's actually an enjoyable character when written properly.

I agree he is but he's way too overrated and that's an understatement. haha No but seriously they need to stop making sound like a god and more like a mutant with basic powers.

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

slayer said:

admin said:

He's actually an enjoyable character when written properly.

I agree he is but he's way too overrated and that's an understatement. haha No but seriously they need to stop making sound like a god and more like a mutant with basic powers.

Well recently he moved out of molten steel with no nerves or tendons.

[kuwabara]

speculation. It likly his tendon were still there and it even more speculation t assume it was molten steel

[Magic attack]

kuwabara said:

speculation. It likly his tendon were still there and it even more speculation t assume it was molten steel

I would just like to read what you think it was that he was dipped into. It appears to be a vat of molten steel.


img181.imageshack.us/my.php?image=wolverineannual0138mx8.jpg

img72.imageshack.us/my.php?image=wolverineannual0139ie7.jpg

img72.imageshack.us/my.php?image=wolverineannual0140wj2.jpg


Not saying anyone is wrong, just stating what it appears to be.

[kuwabara]

I agree it look like molten steel, but it stil speculation. It could have been any number of things.

also many people think he was a walking skeleton I don't agree. Seems like it still had muscles and such in certain area's such as he did in the plane crash in wolverine 51 I believe

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

kuwabara said:

I agree it look like molten steel, but it stil speculation. It could have been any number of things.

also many people think he was a walking skeleton I don't agree. Seems like it still had muscles and such in certain area's such as he did in the plane crash in wolverine 51 I believe

So there was no need to debate it then was there? I mean if you agreed. From what I see in the pic there was nothing there but skeleton, but that is just me. There's nothing wrong with saying he has an inconsistency here and then. I think every character has had them before.

[Magic attack]

kuwabara said:

I agree it look like molten steel, but it stil speculation. It could have been any number of things.

also many people think he was a walking skeleton I don't agree. Seems like it still had muscles and such in certain area's such as he did in the plane crash in wolverine 51 I believe

Atleast you can admit it looks like Molten steel. The frame after the ones that I showed has the bad guy mention that Wolverine is now a Lava Smoothie.



There are plenty of inferences that can be made from the scans, but Kuwabara is correct; they are just speculation for the time being.

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

shakezula said:

kuwabara said:

I agree it look like molten steel, but it stil speculation. It could have been any number of things.

also many people think he was a walking skeleton I don't agree. Seems like it still had muscles and such in certain area's such as he did in the plane crash in wolverine 51 I believe

Atleast you can admit it looks like Molten steel. The frame after the ones that I showed has the bad guy mention that Wolverine is now a Lava Smoothie.



There are plenty of inferences that can be made from the scans, but Kuwabara is correct; they are just speculation for the time being.

That is true I was just wondering the defense if it was in agreement.

[JACK-2]

Wolverine is not winning this and will be the first one to lose. While physical ability is very important. . .There is nothing in my opinion to suggest that his is above Batman or Cap. He has nice regen and strong resistance due to admantium. But, his regen will not do him any good if he can still be K.O.ed and his fighting skills cannot compare to that of Batman let alone Caps.

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

Dec 10, 2008 14:50:43 GMT -5 JACK-2 said:

Wolverine is not winning this and will be the first one to lose. While physical ability is very important. . .There is nothing in my opinion to suggest that his is above Batman or Cap. He has nice regen and strong resistance due to admantium. But, his regen will not do him any good if he can still be K.O.ed and his fighting skills cannot compare to that of Batman let alone Caps.

Wolverine fanboys would eat you alive for that comment. But yea, he really isn't leagues above them, and he can be ko'ed. Wolverine was more reasonable when I was at KMC, and then people made him stronger, faster, and insanely durable. Well a select few people. I don't know though, he is really skilled, he just doesn't use it as he doesn't need it. But then again why hurt yourself if you don't have to by fighting recklessly.

[JACK-2]

I've never argued Wolverine fanboys, but judging from your accounts of them I wouldn't want too. :gulp:

I think he's skilled as well, but he's never struck me as anymore skilled than Cap.

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

Dec 12, 2008 16:45:11 GMT -5 JACK-2 said:

I've never argued Wolverine fanboys, but judging from your accounts of them I wouldn't want too. :gulp:

I think he's skilled as well, but he's never struck me as anymore skilled than Cap.

They are both a level 7 in fighting, which means they have knowledge of *all* fighting. Which I think is an overstatement.

The stories I could tell, he's gotten more powerful on there since I left.

[JACK-2]

Fighting knowledge and Fighting skill are two different things, though. Wolverine just lacks the tactics, resourcefulness and level headiness to touch cap. Hell, I think Cyclops despite being underrated as hell can be just as skilled as Wolvie despite seemingly having less knowledge. Marvel can't have us believe that on average wolverine can be both a master of fighting and a wild raging berserker. It's contradictory, he's great at stealth I'll give him that, but when he goes all out he makes decisions that Cap just would not make.

If we count wolverine now I guess he wins being the worst written character I've known for a while.

[The Big Daddy C-Master]

Dec 13, 2008 2:19:01 GMT -5 JACK-2 said:

Fighting knowledge and Fighting skill are two different things, though. Wolverine just lacks the tactics, resourcefulness and level headiness to touch cap. Hell, I think Cyclops despite being underrated as hell can be just as skilled as Wolvie despite seemingly having less knowledge. Marvel can't have us believe that on average wolverine can be both a master of fighting and a wild raging berserker. It's contradictory, he's great at stealth I'll give him that, but when he goes all out he makes decisions that Cap just would not make.

If we count wolverine now I guess he wins being the worst written character I've known for a while.

Damn, you think he's that bad now?

[JACK-2]

You don't?

Some of the things he's done are so silly it's hard to take him seriously.